Thursday, January 29, 2015

In Flannery O'Connor's short story "Revelation," how are the references to hogs and pigs thematically significant?

Flannery O’Connor uses references to pigs, hogs, and even
warthogs in her story “Revelation” in various ways. Here are a number of ways in which
such references are employed:


  1. The hogs are among
    the various material possessions in which Mrs. Turpin takes pride. Since pride is her
    crucial flaw (as it is, O’Connor would have said, in all human beings), Mrs. Turpin’s
    pride in owning hogs is just one example of her more general tendency to inflate her
    self-importance. In addition, the hogs are also one example of her general tendency to
    value material possessions over spiritual
    values

  2. References to hogs are among the ways by which
    O’Connor satirizes Mrs. Turpin’s pretensions.  When Mrs. Turpin claims, for instance,
    that her hogs are “‘not dirty and do not stink’” (693), most readers will laugh, for
    several possible reasons. In the first place, Mrs. Turpin’s claim is highly unlikely to
    be true. In the second place, if it is true, that fact implies that
    Mrs. Turpin is much too concerned with superficial cleanliness and is insufficiently
    concerned with the kind of spiritual cleanliness that mattered most to O’Connor. Rather
    than devoting so much attention to keeping her hogs clean, Mrs. Turpin (O’Connor
    implies) should be more concerned with the cleanliness of her own
    soul.

  3. Mrs. Turpin uses the hogs, at one point, in
    severely judging another human being.  Thus, she says of her hogs, “‘They’re cleaner
    than some children I’ve seen’” (693). This is obviously a snide remark about the dirty,
    unkempt child who is sitting with Mrs. Turpin in the doctor’s office. Mrs. Turpin seems
    to value her hogs more highly than she values a child who is probably physically sick.
    Rather than showing compassion toward the child, she boasts about her hogs. The child
    may be sick physically, but Mrs. Turpin is sick
    spiritually.

  4. Later in the story, Mrs. Turpin sprays one
    old sow in the eye with a water hose, paying no attention to the pain of the squealing
    hog (702). This incident epitomizes Mrs. Turpin’s self-absorption, and it may also imply
    her willingness to cause pain to others without really considering what she is doing. A
    little later, in fact, she seems deliberately to jab baby pigs with the stream of water
    – an incident that suggests a malevolence deep in her nature.

  5. Mrs. Turpin cannot stand the thought that she has been
    compared, by Mary Grace, to a warthog. The accusation has shaken her pride, but it is
    precisely her pride that needs to be shaken. In a sense, Mrs. Turpin must learn that she
    really is little better than a hog, at least in the eyes of God. He cares nothing for
    all her material possessions and her social pretensions.

  6. The final reference to hogs in the story (703) implies
    that the hogs are actually living lives more in conformance with God’s design for them
    than is true of Mrs. Turpin. The hogs have all settled “in one corner around the old sow
    who was grunting softly. A red glow suffused them. They appeared to pant with a secret
    life.” They are more in harmony with their fellow creatures and with the rest of God’s
    creation than Mrs. Turpin has been for a very long time. Ironically, there is something
    beautiful about this final depiction of the hogs, whereas Mrs. Turpin, for much of the
    story, has been ugly in a wide variety of
    ways.

O’Connor, Flannery. “Revelation.”
The Art of the Short Story. Ed. Dana Goia and R. S. Gwynn. New
York: Pearson Longman, 2006. 689-704.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Calculate tan(x-y), if sin x=1/2 and sin y=1/3. 0

We'll write the formula of the tangent of difference of 2 angles. tan (x-y) = (tan x - tan y)/(1 + tan x*tan y) ...