Saturday, July 6, 2013

Regarding Chronicles of a Death Foretold, what is the critical comment listed below based on?A critic states that, "It was not chance but malice...

The story that unfolds in Chapter 1 of
Chronicles of a Death Foretold, is wrapped in the irony of Santiago
Nasar going to meet the Bishop at the pier. In another layer of irony, which doubles as
foreshadowing, the Bishop does not disembark from the boat as Santiago stands,
expectantly waiting, on the pier. This is both irony and foreshadowing because the
Bishop's passing by can be metaphorically understood as the withholding of blessing. The
reason for Santigo's death, which may be interpreted as a withheld blessing, involves
the twins' sister Angela who is returned to her father after her wedding because her
groom discovers she is not a virgin. This represents many kinds of outrage. Angela is
humilated and cast aside by her groom as worthless. The Vicario family is dishonored and
humilated. Angela's (note the irony of the symbolism of her name linking her to angel)
twin brothers must act in revenge. The town becomes co-conspirators in the
revenge.


The story reveals that it is Santigo who is
responsible for Angela's loss of virginity and thus must die by an act of fatal revenge.
The critic you quote posits that chance did not enter into the absence of a warning
because essentially the whole town was complicit in (i.e., indirectly participating in)
the carrying out of the Vicario's revenge against Santiago. This complicity attests to
malice, which is shared outrage at his violation of Angela's womanhood and of her
family's honor. The critic may even go so far as to say that it was part of the
complicity that the town kept Margot from learning of the impending revenge act because
they knew she would try to warn him. Therefore the critic's comment is based upon the
nature of the village moral system and upon what the critic calls the "socio-economic
causes" that drove the revenge, the complicity, and the silence.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Calculate tan(x-y), if sin x=1/2 and sin y=1/3. 0

We'll write the formula of the tangent of difference of 2 angles. tan (x-y) = (tan x - tan y)/(1 + tan x*tan y) ...